5091 Route 9W
5091 Route 9W Newburgh, New York, 12550 United States

 Get directions

About 5091 Route 9W

Strikingly beautiful 1859 Victorian sitting on a hill in Balmville surrounded by Norwegian Spruce. This house, known as the "Thayer House" was constructed under the influence of Thomas Downing. Feat. 5 beds & 2.5 baths, this unique home offers a formal DR & lrg formal LR, wide plank floors and 7 fireplaces! Enter from the grand front porch to the spacious foyer, notice the exquisite LR highlighted with floor to ceiling windows & large window seat. A center sitting room w/marble floors. The oversized FR has 1/2 bath & plenty of room for gatherings & celebrations. Authentic to the home are unique chandeliers bringing warmth & charm along w/the custom designed Quaker made cabinetry in the kitchen. On the 2nd floor the expansive hallway leads to 5 large bdrs. Step down into your MBD w/WI closet, Mbath & FP! Built in bookshelves & 2nd floor laundry! Enjoy the balcony or walk up to the cupola on the 3rd floor! Plenty of room for everyone or perhaps open that B&B you've been dreaming of!


  • Dishwasher
  • Formal Dining Room
  • Pantry
  • Refrigerator
  • walk-in closet(s)
  • Hardwood Flooring
  • Park
  • Ceiling Fan
  • Driveway
  • Near Public Transportation
  • Sloped
  • Wooded
Listing Provided by Angela Danosky, Keller Williams Realty, HGAR MLS
Full Baths
Partial Bath
3,933 Sq Ft.
.51 Acres
Single Family Home
Property Type
Year Built
Newburgh City
School District
Magnet Sch Of Math Science & Design
South Middle School
Newburgh Free Academy

This Newburgh Single Family Home is for Sale and has 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths, 1 partial baths and was built in 1862. This Single Family Home is listed on the Christie's International Real Estate website in zipcode 12550 and it boasts 3,933 Sq.Ft. of interior space on a lot of .51 Acres. Nearby neighborhoods include: Balmville, Balmville and Middlehope. See all properties in zipcode 12550.